Select Page

Steps For Developing A Robust Incident Response Plan For A Law Firm

A cyber incident at a law firm is not only a technology problem. It raises questions about client confidentiality, privilege, ethical obligations, court deadlines, and the firm’s reputation. Firms that handle incidents well do not improvise. They follow a plan that was written, reviewed, and practiced before anything went wrong.

Here are the steps to develop an incident response plan that fits the realities of legal practice.

Step 1: Define What Counts As An Incident

Start with clear definitions. Incidents may include:

  • A compromised email account or suspicious mailbox rules
  • Ransomware or malware on firm systems
  • A lost or stolen laptop or phone
  • A misdirected email containing client information
  • Wire fraud or an attempted payment change
  • Unauthorized access by a current or former employee
  • A breach at a vendor that holds firm data

Make it easy for anyone in the firm to report a suspected incident without fear of blame.

Step 2: Build The Response Team

Identify who will lead and participate:

  • Managing partner or designated executive decision-maker
  • Firm administrator or COO
  • IT lead and your outside IT or security provider
  • General counsel or ethics partner
  • Outside breach counsel
  • Cyber insurance carrier contact
  • Communications lead for client and staff messaging

Keep a contact list with mobile numbers in a printed and offline format.

Step 3: Establish Initial Response Actions

For each incident type, document the first steps. For example, for a compromised mailbox: reset the password, revoke active sessions, confirm MFA, remove malicious rules, and review sent items. For ransomware: disconnect affected devices, avoid powering them off unless instructed, and call your security provider immediately.

Step 4: Preserve Evidence And Privilege

Evidence matters for insurance claims, investigations, and possible legal action. Instruct staff not to wipe or rebuild systems until they are examined. Many firms engage forensic investigators through breach counsel to help protect privilege over investigation findings. Discuss this approach with counsel in advance.

Step 5: Notify Your Cyber Insurer Early

Most cyber policies require prompt notice and may require using approved forensic and legal vendors. Know your policy number, notification process, and panel providers before an incident occurs.

Step 6: Assess Client Impact And Notification Duties

Determine what client information was involved and which clients were affected. Work with counsel to evaluate obligations under state breach notification laws, contractual commitments in engagement letters or outside counsel guidelines, and professional responsibility rules regarding client communication.

Step 7: Maintain Operations And Deadlines

Court deadlines do not pause for cyber incidents. Plan how attorneys will access critical documents, calendars, and e-filing if primary systems are unavailable. Consider whether courts or opposing counsel need to be informed about delays.

Step 8: Communicate Carefully

Prepare templates for staff, clients, and external inquiries. Use a single spokesperson. If email may be compromised, establish alternate communication channels.

Step 9: Recover And Strengthen

Restore systems from clean, tested backups. Reset credentials, patch vulnerabilities, and close the gap that allowed the incident. Monitor closely for signs the attacker is still present.

Step 10: Review Lessons Learned

After the incident, hold a review to identify what worked and what did not. Update the plan, policies, and technical controls accordingly.

Step 11: Practice Annually

Run a tabletop exercise each year with firm leadership. A realistic scenario, such as a partner’s email being used to redirect a settlement payment, quickly shows whether everyone knows their role.

Prevention Reduces The Load

A strong plan is easier to execute when good controls are already in place: MFA, email security, managed EDR, tested backups, and staff training. Together they reduce how often the plan is needed and how severe incidents become.

CTS Companies helps Michigan firms prepare for and respond to incidents through our cybersecurity services for law firms, including 24/7 monitoring and recovery support. Talk to an expert about building your plan.