Skip to content
CTS Field Notes

Hacks

Who Unlocked the Sample Files?

A federal indictment describes how opened samples helped sell ransomware recovery. The case shows what a buyer can verify before authorizing the larger job.

Imagine that your business has been hacked and its files encrypted. You hire a firm that says it can help with this exact issue using proprietary software to decrypt the data. You send two encrypted files to the ransomware recovery firm, and those files come back readable. With operations disrupted and more data still out of reach, that demonstration gives your business a reason to authorize the larger recovery job. Should that help build trust? Do you want to know what is happening behind the scenes?

Consider the real-life case of MonsterCloud. Federal prosecutors allege that, in many cases involving the company, the people who opened those samples were the same people who had locked them. The firm’s owner then returned the samples to customers as evidence of its recovery capabilities.

What prosecutors allege MonsterCloud promised

MonsterCloud is a Florida ransomware recovery company. Prosecutors allege that its owner, Zohar Pinhasi, marketed proprietary technology that could recover encrypted files without paying attackers. They say he instead secretly paid attackers for decryption keys, using part of the fees customers paid his company.

That is the alleged deception: selling customers one explanation of how their files would be recovered while concealing another. The charges concern alleged fraud against recovery customers, not an allegation that Pinhasi carried out the original ransomware attacks. Federal indictment.

On October 7, Pinhasi pleaded not guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and two counts of wire fraud. The charges are allegations, and he is presumed innocent. The public docket reviewed on November 11 listed a November 9 status conference and a continuance order, followed by a letter filed November 10 whose contents were unavailable in the public mirror. Court docket and arraignment minutes.

In a 2019 interview with ProPublica, Pinhasi said MonsterCloud did not mislead clients or promise a particular recovery method. That was his position years before the indictment. ProPublica investigation.

The contracts add another distinction. According to the indictment, some allowed contact with or payment to attackers, sometimes only after other recovery options were exhausted. Prosecutors allege that contacting the attackers was generally Pinhasi’s first step.

What a successful sample test tells you

Two readable files give a customer something useful to examine. They do not, by themselves, establish where the decryption capability came from or whether the remaining files can be restored.

A customer should open returned samples in the applications that use them and have someone familiar with the records check their contents. A spreadsheet that opens but is missing information may not help the business resume operations.

The recovery vendor should also explain how it obtained the means to open the files. Was it restoring a backup, using an available decryption tool, or working with the attacker? Who received the samples? What does that result establish about the remaining data?

Those questions do not require a vendor to reveal its software. They ask for enough information to understand and authorize the work.

Choose the recovery vendor before you need one

A business whose systems are down has little patience for checking references and comparing contract language. Every additional hour creates pressure to accept the first credible promise of recovery.

Do that work while the business is running normally. Identify who you would call, speak with them, and understand what their role would be. If you carry cyber insurance, check the policy’s notification and vendor-approval requirements before committing to a provider.

A useful conversation goes beyond “Can you get our files back?”

  • Who will do the work? Identify the company, the response team and any subcontractors. Ask for independently checkable references from comparable incidents.
  • What are we buying? Clarify whether the engagement covers file recovery alone or also investigating the intrusion, containing it and helping the business restore safe operations.
  • What needs our approval? Set written rules for sharing files, contacting attackers, making payments and expanding the work. Name the person at your company who can authorize each step.
  • How will we know what happened? Agree on progress reports, recovery tests and a bill that distinguishes the vendor’s services from outside payments.

Keep those answers and contact details somewhere accessible if company systems are unavailable. Review them when vendors, insurance coverage or key staff change.

None of this guarantees an honest vendor or a successful recovery. It gives the business time to examine claims, understand limitations and resolve uncomfortable questions before a shutdown makes every answer feel urgent.

The sample files matter. So does knowing whose hands they passed through. The best time to establish how a recovery vendor earns your trust is before you are depending on it to reopen the business.